Monday, 20 December 2021

Short Q and A on Public International Law: Part 6

Vande Matram!

These are some one-liner notes on Public International Law. Read them carefully and note them for your knowledge.

Short Q and A on Public International Law: Part 6

 

·         What are the examples of law-making treaties?

o   Examples of law-making treaties are:

§  Pact of Paris 1956;

§  Hague conventions of 1899 & 1907,

§  Peace Treaty 1919,

§  Treaty for the Renunciation of War, 1929,

§  Geneva Convention relating to Prisoners of War 1929,

§  Conventions of the Law of the Sea Conference 1958, etc

·         What does international custom manifest?

o   This is the original source of international law and it manifests

§  Diplomatic Correspondence of States,

§  Practice of International Organisations

§  State Court's decisions,

§  State Practice

§  Administrative actions

·         What is custom?

o   Custom is the practice of rules for many years and such practice is continuous and uniform.

·         What are tests of custom?

o   Custom has to satisfy the following tests to become the source of law:

§  Corpus test

§  Animus test

·         What is a corpus test?

o   Corpus test is a material fact of the actual observance of a line of conduct by the States.

·         What is meant by the animus test?

o   Animus test means there must be an intention to follow the custom.

·         When will General Principles of law be recognised by Civilized Nations applied?

o   If there is no International Treaty or International Custom, the court applies General Principles of law recognised by Civilized Nations

·         What is an essential duty of the Court?

o   One of the essential duties of the Court is to decide the case and not to plead its inability or helplessness on the ground that the law is silent or obscure. Hence, it may evolve a process to arrive at a general principle by taking into consideration the Municipal laws of the major countries of the World.

·         When a rule of municipal law can be declared as the rule of international law?

o   If the Court finds that a rule has been accepted generally as a fundamental rule of justice by most Nations in their Municipal Law, it may be declared as a rule of International Law.

·         What judicial precedents are used as the source of international law?

o   The decisions of the I.C.J., the P.C.I.J., the International Arbitration Tribunals, and the National Supreme Courts form the fourth source of International Law.

·         How international law is meant for individuals of a state?

o   As Westlake opines 'The rights & duties of the States are ultimately the rights and duties of men that compose them. Hence, though the States are normal subjects, they may endow the individuals with International rights & duties and to that extent make them subjects of International law.

·         How pirates are subject of international law?

o   Pirates who commit Piracy Jure Gentium on the high seas are liable to punishment under International law. To that extent, they are the subjects of International law, but some jurists call them objects.

·         How slaves are subject of international law?

o   International convention has provided for the abolition of slavery. The convention also provides for the rights of the slaves. They enjoy these rights as subjects of International law.

·         What is Belligerent?

o   Belligerent means a nation or person engaged in war or conflict, as recognized by international law.


Thanks for reading till the end. Thanks for reading till the end. Please share this article with all law aspirants, students, and professionals.

Read More

============

#PublicInternationalLaw #OneLinerNotes #StudyMaterial #ExamPreparation #QnA #ShartQuestionAndAnswer

https://notesdynamo.blogspot.com/2021/12/pil-qna-part5.html

#BharatMataKiJay

==========

Short Q and A on Public International Law: Part 5

Vande Matram!

These are some one-liner notes on Public International Law. Read them carefully and note them for your knowledge.

Short Q and A on Public International Law: Part 5

 

·         What is international law?

o   International Law is defined as a body of principles & rules commonly observed by States in their mutual relationship with each other.

·         What are the contents of international law?

o   International law includes law relating to

§  States

§  international organisations

§  international institutions

§  non-State entities

§  individuals

·         Who opined that international law has only moral force?

o   Austin opined that International Law was not law at all and called it a 'Positive International Morality' and hence it had only moral force.

·         What is the opinion of Holland on international law?

o   Holland said that international law was at the vanishing point of jurisprudence.

·         How customary rules and rules of morality are founded?

o   Customary rules or rules of morality are founded on conscience.

·         Who forms the international community?

o   States form the international community.

·         What is the content of the body of international rules?

o   Body of international rules includes treaties, international customs, Declarations by international conferences of States, Conventions ratified by nations, UN charters, International Court of Justice Statute, etc.

·         Give examples of enforcement of international law?

o   Following are the examples of international law:

§  Pacific settlement under the UN charter

§  Self-help of states

§  Punishment of offenders

§  Resolving political questions through General Assembly or Security Council

§  Arbitration procedures are there for resolving civil and commercial matters at the international level

§  Interpol is also there for sanction of criminal activities

·         Who said that ‘weak law is also a law’?

o   Oppenheim concluded, Compared to Municipal Law, international law is a weak law, but a weak law is still a law.

·         What is meant by ‘source of law’?

o   ‘Source of law’ means the ultimate origin from which the law originates.

·         What are the sources of law as per Article 38 of the ICJ Statute:

o   Article 38 of the ICJ Statute provides the following sources of international law based on primacy before the court:

§  a) International Conventions or treaties.

§  b) International Customary Law.

§  c) General Principles of law recognised by Civilised Nations.

§  d) Judicial Precedents.

§  e) Juristic Writings.

§  f) Ex aequo et bono. (Equity & good conscience)

·         What are the types of treaties?

o   Treaties are of two types:

§  (i) Law-making  

§  (ii) Treaty-contract


Thanks for reading till the end. Thanks for reading till the end. Please share this article with all law aspirants, students, and professionals.

Read More

============

#PublicInternationalLaw #OneLinerNotes #StudyMaterial #ExamPreparation #QnA #ShartQuestionAndAnswer

https://notesdynamo.blogspot.com/2021/12/pil-qna-part4.html

#BharatMataKiJay

==========

Short Q and A on Public International Law: Part 4

Vande Matram!

These are some one-liner notes on Public International Law. Read them carefully and note them for your knowledge.

Short Q and A on Public International Law: Part 4


·         How international law is incorporated into monist theory?

o   According to monist approaches, international law ought to be automatically incorporated into the domestic legal order, without the requirement of any additional act of adoption or transformation by the state.

·         Who provides recognition of the authority of municipal law in monist theory?

o   Monism rationalizes the interconnectedness of the international and domestic legal spheres on the understanding that it is international law that provides the recognition necessary for the authority of municipal law to operate over a given subject or territory.

·         How international law is incorporated in municipal law in dualist theory?

o   In dualist theory since international and domestic laws operate in distinct spheres, the only mechanism for the transformation of international law into domestic law is through the medium of regular domestic law-making processes.

·         What are the concerns of monistic theory?

o   Monist values are rationalized within contemporary discourses as promoting/reflecting a cosmopolitan culture and the universalisation of value, as well as serving the imperatives of global governance.

·         What are the concerns of dualist theory?

o   Dualism on the other hand has been reinforced in recent writings as a valuable device for preserving/promoting international legal pluralism; as protecting the distinct and self-expressive nature of domestic law; and as indispensable for the proper functioning of domestic democratic processes for the creation of coercive legal norms, instead of rule by a 'new political elite of international lawyers.' At the same time, concerns about the (lack of) participatory and (un) democratic nature of the processes of international law-making and concerns regarding their substantive content are often posited as supports for dualist positions.

·         What is the main requirement of international law to get implemented in any State?

o   The main requirement of international law to get implemented in any State is ‘legislative approval’ of that particular treaty or principle of international law, whatever may be the theory of that State to apply the international law within the domestic sphere.

·         What is the base of Article 51 of the Constitution of India?

o   The language of Article 51 of the Constitution of India is based on the Havana Declaration, 1939

·         When and where Havana Declaration was adopted?

o   Havana Declaration was adopted at the Second Conference of American State Members of the International Labour Organization, 1939.

·         How Article 51 of the Constitution of India helps in the implementation of international law in India?

o   Article 51 of the Constitution of India clearly intended to guide India’s foreign policy and form the basis of its international relations, rather than provide for how India should approach its international law obligations domestically. Clearly, it gives guidance to form the basis of international relations but does not give any specific procedure to implement international law.

·         How does the Parliament of India is having legislative competence over foreign affairs?

o   Article 246, read with entries 10–14 of the Union List of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution (enumerating powers of the Union), provides that legislative competence over foreign affairs, over entering into treaties with foreign countries and implementing them domestically, lies with Parliament.

·         Under which Article of Constitution Parliament of India can make laws for implementation of international obligations?

o   Article 253 of the Constitution clarifies that the power of Parliament to make law for the implementation of international obligations extends even to those matters that are otherwise within the legislative competence of states.


 

Thanks for reading till the end. Thanks for reading till the end. Please share this article with all law aspirants, students, and professionals.

Read More

============

#PublicInternationalLaw #OneLinerNotes #StudyMaterial #ExamPreparation #QnA #ShartQuestionAndAnswer

https://notesdynamo.blogspot.com/2021/12/pil-qna-part3.html

#BharatMataKiJay

==========

Short Q and A on Public International Law: Part 3

 Vande Matram!

These are some one-liner notes on Public International Law. Read them carefully and note them for your knowledge.

Short Q and A on Public International Law: Part 3


·         What is a non-self-executing treaty?

o   A non-self-executing treaty directly incorporated, but need for additional implementing legislation before application in the domestic system.

·         How municipal and international laws are implemented in USSR/Soviet Russia/Russia?

o   In USSR, as per Article 29 of the Soviet constitution, municipal law and international law were treated as two separate legal systems not subordinate to each other.

·         What are the principles of the USSR with other states?

o   As per Article 29 of the Soviet constitution the relation of the USSR with other states were based on the following principles:

§  Sovereign equality

§  Mutual renunciation of threat or use of force

§  Territorial integrity of states

§  Peaceful settlement of disputes

§  Non-intervention in internal affairs

§  Respect to human rights and fundamental freedoms

§  Co-operations among states

§  Fulfilment in good faith of obligations arising from generally recognised principles, rules of international law, from treaties signed by the USSR

§  In USSR international treaties and internal statutes were given equal statutes.

·         How does India follow the implementation of International Law in the State?

o   India follows the Dualism and Transformation and adoption

·         What was the practice of implementation of International Law in India before enforcement of its Constitution?

o   British Practice

·         What are the constitutional provisions of the implementation of international law in India?

o   Following are the constitutional provisions of the implementation of international law in India:

§  General art. 51

§  Executive Provisions art. 53, 73, & 77

§  Legislative Provisions art. 245, 253

·         How customary rules were treated in British Practice?

o   British used to treat customary rules of international law as a part of their own laws. But subject to the conditions that the customary rules of International law should not be inconsistent (should be consistent) with the British statutes.

·         What is British practice regarding rules laid by treaties?

o   In British practice, rules laid by treaties need consent from British Parliament and such rules can be adopted in the State laws with the help of the statutes by the parliament.

·         What are the provisions of Article 51 of the Constitution of India to implement international law?

o   Article 51 of the Constitution of India provides that State (India) should endeavour to

§  promote international peace and security

§  maintain just and honorable relations between nations

§  foster respect for international law & treaty obligations in dealings of organised people with one another.

§  Encourage settlement of international disputes by arbitration.


Thanks for reading till the end. Thanks for reading till the end. Please share this article with all law aspirants, students, and professionals.

Read More

============

#PublicInternationalLaw #OneLinerNotes #StudyMaterial #ExamPreparation #QnA #ShartQuestionAndAnswer

https://notesdynamo.blogspot.com/2021/12/pil-qna-part2.html

#BharatMataKiJay

==========